Constant Contact #Fail. Subscribers on ONE list can not join any additional lists.
Once a subscriber is onto one list at Constant Contact, the same subscriber can NOT join any additional lists.
This occurs via the 3rd party plugins of Thrive Themes as well as Ninja Forms.
That is a fatal flaw that puts our entire system of contact management with customers at jeopardy.
Here is how you can test it (with Thrive Themes):
- Go to this page: /get-news-emails/
- Then sign up for one list. Fine. Works.
- Then sign up for another list -- and you get an error message.
See attached screen shot below with the little pink area showing the error.
How can you fix this? Please advise.

Update from Tech Support at Thrive Themes
The issue is clearly a Constant Contact problem
Hey Mark,
Thanks for granting us access. I'm sorry to hear that you're having issues with your form.
I duplicated your page, saved it as a draft, tested the form and was able to replicate the issue. Please watch until 0.46 seconds of the screencast https://share.getcloudapp.com/bLu5BPe5.
I went ahead and replicated it on my test site and got the same result. Please watch from 0.49 to the end. https://share.getcloudapp.com/bLu5BPe5
I checked our backlog and found an existing bug report about this issue has been raised, so I've added a vote on your behalf.
The ticket ID is SUPP-14975, in case you want to follow up about it.
More: The development team has responded regarding the issue.
The reason for the error is that Constant Contact API does not support adding the same contact. Please see – https://share.getcloudapp.com/BluWGln2.
Kindly note that this is handled by the Constant Contact API and not by us. If it's not much of a hassle, we recommend using another platform that supports this.
Via CC Chat
Hey I just had a chat with the back end, They have request you to send an email to webservices -at- constantcontact -dot- com which is our developer team email, They will check into this and get back to you as soon as possible, While sending the email please do mention your username. Sorry for all the trouble caused.
Two Constant Contact Usernames:
- Rauterkus
- Mark@Rauterkus.com
While you wait for a response, please feel free to search our developer forum for answers or discussions related to your question, or view our API Documentation.The Developers Forum can be found here:https://community.constantcontact.com/t5/Developer-Community/ct-p/developercommunityAPI Documentation for our new V3 API can be found here:https://v3.developer.constantcontact.com/api_guide/index.htmlAPI Documentation for our older V2 API is located here:http://developer.constantcontact.com/docs/developer-guides/api-documentation-index.html
Reply from Constant Contact's Developer
Thank you for reaching out to Constant Contact API Developer Support. My team is here to assist outside software developers with questions about building into Constant Contact's API.It looks like the 3rd party integration associated with the form on your website is adding new contacts successfully, but is returning a 409 response error in our logs and is not updating existing contacts who fill out the form, which means that the developers who built that integration did not account for updating existing contacts, only adding new ones. Typically a 409 error response occurs when making a POST call to the /contacts endpoint for an existing contact, which can only add new contacts whose email addresses have not previously been added to the account.Once a contact (email address) has been added into the system, even if it is deleted, the contact entry and details still remain on the back end of the system for reporting and compliance purposes. When using the API, there are a couple of different endpoint options to bypass the 409 response but they must be programmed into the integration/form/plugin by the 3rd party that developed it.
Typically this error occurs when making a POST call to the /contacts endpoint, which can only add new contacts whose email addresses have not previously been added to the account.
API Response Codes
https://v3.developer.constantcontact.com/api_guide/glossary_responses.html
Using the example V3* API flow below, the developer of the integration should have their program check to see if an email address exists in the account, and then either create the contact or update the contact. (*Our legacy V2 uses the same flow and call types, but uses a different system.)Step 1: Check to see if the contact exists in the account using the email address.GET Contacts Collectionhttps://v3.developer.constantcontact.com/api_reference/index.html#!/Contacts/getContactsStep 2: If the contact comes back as non-existent, use POST to create the contact:POST (create) a Contacthttps://v3.developer.constantcontact.com/api_reference/index.html#!/Contacts/createContactStep 3: If the contact comes back as already existing in the account, use PUT to update the contact.PUT (update) a Contacthttps://v3.developer.constantcontact.com/api_reference/index.html#!/Contacts/putContactTo resolve this issue, you can either contact the developer of the 3rd party form/plugin/integration you are using to see if they are able to update their application's code, you could switch to a different integration that better meets your needs, or you (and/or your developers) can build/develop your own integration to your organization's specifications.Please have a look and let us know if you have any other questions!Regards,
Courtney E.
Tier II API Support EngineerThanks for the great insights.
Reply from Mark Rauterkus to Webservices at Constant Contact
What if YOU, as in Constant Contact, was able to accept the email input from the web form and put it into a temp file -- and then on your end put the email address into the different list?
It seems as if the workflow you outline above has a lot of heavy lifting to be done by a lead generation form.
So, I also wonder, if there are OTHER web form integrations that don't break upon this hurdle? All the forms that I use (the Upside Plugin, NinjaForms, ThriveThemes) don't work with Constant Contact, after one is subscribed to one list.
But, I will forward this email to the developers on these other software programs and see if they can be of some help. However, I have a good idea that they are going to suggest that I switch to a different email provider.
- I am wondering about a Workaround with TAGS?If an email is on a list, can we add a new tag to the existing email address with a web form?
I've got to find a way to segment the names in our Constant Contact database.
A week later, more info from an email from Constant Contact with little value, except the links, which we already knew.
As far as adding tags upon signup, there are several different ways that a tag could be added to a 3rd party form or integration using one or more additional API calls, but again, this would need to be programmed into the code by the developer.
An easy alternative would be to use additional lists, one as the desired mailing list, and one as the placeholder for the tag, and then have the call add the sign-up to both lists.In this case, the code modifications would need to be made by the third party developer that created the app, as the endpoints and parameters that they choose determine how the integration attempts to add contacts into Constant Contact.You may be able to find a different 3rd party developed form/integration that batter meets your needs, but as another option, Constant Contact offers a variety of pre-built hard-coded sign-up forms that are easy to design and install that will allow you to add website-signups directly from your website into your Constant Contact account, that allow users to be added to multiple lists without returning a 409 code. (However, they do not offer the option to include tags upon sign-up)Create a pop-up contact sign-up form for your websitehttp://knowledgebase.constantcontact.com/articles/KnowledgeBase/21407-Create-a-Pop-up-Sign-Up-FormCreate an inline contact sign-up form to embed on a websitehttp://knowledgebase.constantcontact.com/articles/KnowledgeBase/18265-Create-a-Sign-Up-Form-with-the-new-sign-up-form-experienceActivate and install an inline or pop-up contact sign-up form on a websitehttp://knowledgebase.constantcontact.com/articles/KnowledgeBase/18053-activating-and-installing-your-sign-up-formCreate a Lead Generation Landing Page for capturing new sign-upshttps://knowledgebase.constantcontact.com/articles/KnowledgeBase/32012-Create-a-Lead-Generation-Landing-Page-for-Capturing-New-Sign-Ups-to-Your-Contact-List
Source: helpdesk.WordPress.2026-06-05.xml · Original ID: 3406